The U.K. government has been ordered to confirm that it issued a secret order demanding Apple to provide authorities with encrypted customer information.
The Thursday ruling from the U.K.’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal, an independent court that allows citizens to challenge government surveillance orders, is a rare rebuke for the government, which sought to keep the encryption backdoor order a state secret.
The tribunal’s ruling rejected the Home Office’s claim that disclosing the order would be damaging to national security.
The ruling comes a year after the U.K. government reportedly demanded that Apple build a backdoor to allow U.K. authorities access to customer data anywhere in the world. Details of the so-called “technical capabilities notice,” which are issued under strict non-disclosure rules, leaked to the media, which drew ire from White House officials and U.S. lawmakers who criticized the effort, arguing that the U.K. order would put Americans’ privacy at risk.
Context, for anyone not following this story: In February 2025, news broke that the UK government had secretly issued “a technical capability notice” that demanded that Apple create a backdoor into iCloud. Ten days later, Apple issued a statement that it “can no longer offer Advanced Data Protection (ADP) in the United Kingdom,” preventing new users from enabling the fully end-to-end encrypted feature and requiring existing users to disable it, saying that it has “never built a backdoor or master key to any of our products or services and we never will.” The statement and decision to pull ADP were widely seen as a response to the secret request, but neither Apple nor the British government were commenting publicly. A month later, Google refused to deny receiving its own secret order from the UK, further fueling speculation.
Apple appealed the UK demand in an also-secret hearing. Now, we may finally confirm the speculation that the British government did in fact demand a secret backdoor into iCloud.
