After my recent comment that “I’m a big believer in owning physical copies of media I love,” an old friend asked me on Facebook:
Do you ever buy streaming rights for life as opposed to a 1-3 day rental? You can download movies to your device if you have spotty internet.
I very rarely “buy” streaming movies or TV shows, and I definitely don’t consider those “purchases” to be “for life.” I’m using scare quotes liberally here because you and I don’t own that content. It’s merely licensed to us and that license can be revoked by the rights holder at any time. It isn’t ours. Unlike a hardcover book or a DVD boxed set, we can’t loan it to a friend or hand it down to our movie-obsessed niece or cousin.
Buying a streamed movie is not logistically much different from paying to rent a movie, except that when you pay Apple $5.99 to rent Project Hail Mary, you know you’ll lose access to it 48 hours after you start watching, but when you “buy,” that end date is unknown. Like death, we know it’s coming, we just don’t know when. If we’re very lucky, it’s a very long time from now, but there’s no escaping it—we will eventually lose access to our “purchased” streaming videos. At the very latest, it’ll happen when we die—there’s no right of survivorship for digital media.
(This is true even for the digital code that comes with many Blu-ray and DVD discs.)
I experienced rights revocation first-hand. In 2009, Amazon secretly yanked copies of 1984 from customers’ Kindle libraries, including my own. Yes, really. Yes, 1984. The absurdity wasn’t lost on anyone.
Which is not to say I never “buy” digital media. Recently, for example, I “bought” the two-season boxed set of Sports Night, Aaron Sorkin’s cancelled-too-soon comedy, for $10. Apple normally (and currently) sells that boxed set for $15 per season. But! I had already bought the DVDs 20 (!) years ago and digitally ripped them. Now, I have a higher-quality version that’s more easily streamable. At $10, I was willing to take a flyer that Apple might pull an Amazon—and I recognize that the digital purchase dies with me. But the DVDs can be passed to my heirs. (You’re welcome, heirs.)
So no, I almost never “buy” just “streaming rights.” I buy physical copies of media I truly care about “owning.” I may also buy a digital copy to ease my near-term consumption if the price is right, with the clear understanding that those digital copies can poof, disappear.
⚙︎




