Supported by Fastmail
Sponsor: Fastmail

Fast, private email hosting for you or your business. Try Fastmail free for up to 30 days.

Supreme Court’s Conservatives Issued ‘the Worst Ruling in a Century’

Richard L. Hasen, writing for Slate (paywalled; Apple News+, and Raw Story’s summary):

Wednesday’s 6–3 party-line decision in Louisiana v. Callais will go down in history as one of the most pernicious and damaging Supreme Court decisions of the past century. All six Republican-appointed justices on the court signed onto Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion gutting what remained of the Voting Rights Act protections for minority voters, while pretending they were merely making technical tweaks to the act.

This decision will bleach the halls of Congress, state legislatures, and local bodies like city councils, by ending the protections of Section 2 of the act, which had provided a pathway to assure that voters of color would have some rudimentary fair representation. It’s the culmination of the life’s work of Chief Justice John Roberts and Samuel Alito, who have shown persistent resistance to the idea of the United States as a multiracial democracy, and a brazen willingness to reject Congress’ judgment that fair representation for minority voters sometimes requires race-conscious legislation. It gives the green light to further partisan gerrymandering. It protects Alito’s core constituency: aggrieved white Republican voters. It’s a disaster for American democracy.

Hasen concludes:

The Supreme Court itself has shown itself to be the enemy of democracy. If and when Democrats retake control of the political branches, it will be incumbent on them not only to write new voting legislation protecting minority voters and all voters in the ability to participate fairly in elections that reflect the will of all the people; they will also have to consider reform of the Supreme Court itself, a conclusion I had been resisting until the court made this unavoidable.

I have nothing to add other than this decision utterly destroys what little remaining optimism I’ve held for this country. We’ve lost so much of the ideals of a “democracy” in the last few years (longer, if I’m being completely honest) that I’m no longer confident we have the capacity—or the inclination—to restore and defend it. At least not in my lifetime. I’m not quite ready to give up the fight, but I’m awfully tired of fighting for something so few others seem to care about.

⚙︎

Subscribe to JAG’s Workshop to get new posts by email, and follow JAG’s Workshop using RSS, Mastodon, Bluesky, or LinkedIn . You can also support the site with a one-time tip of any amount.